ARAB
MEDIA WATCH
By Dr. Joseph Lerner.
Excerpts: Moslem
Brotherhood on Cairo campus. Libyan justice. 16 October 2005
AL AHRAM WEEKLY 13-19 Oct.'05:"Louder and louder"
HEADING: "The banned Muslim Brotherhood is gearing up for a greater role on
university campuses, reports Mustafa El-Menshawy"
In 2003, Cairo University students belonging to the banned Muslim Brotherhood
group placed a large banner on campus welcoming their fellow students back
from summer break. The banner was signed "Islamist students". This week,
a group of Brotherhood students put up a new banner promoting reform. The
signature at the bottom this time was different; it bluntly said, "Muslim
Brotherhood students". The willingness to directly identify themselves in this
manner was a significant change for the group. A similar dynamic was in play
during the nationwide protests that took place at several universities less
than two weeks ago, when thousands of student members of the Muslim
Brotherhood demonstrated for democratic reforms. Previous campus protests
organised by the group had, like the banners, merely gathered under the
more general Islamist moniker. Just what the outlawed group, widely considered
Egypt's largest opposition entity, is trying to prove with the newfound
approach, and why now, are the two key questions being asked in the wake of
the protests." We demand an end to restrictions on political activities on
campus," said one of the group's student members, who would only reveal his
first name, Said. The Brotherhood's demands, he said, also included more
political freedoms off campus, including social justice, fair elections, and
an abolishment of the emergency law. During the demonstrations, the protestors
raised banners that said, "Together for reform: free university, free
country." A day earlier, they held another protest demanding that the
university administration reverse its decision to prevent 200 students from
using campus housing for "security" reasons. "I am being prevented from
staying at the hostel for unjust reasons," said a Brotherhood student on
condition of anonymity. He said he was being forced to commute to university
on a daily basis from his Delta governorate home, since he could not otherwise
afford to stay in Cairo on his own." The student hostel is heavily subsidised.
Prominent Muslim Brotherhood figure Abdel-Moneim Abul-Futuh said the student
protests had taken place based on "the recommendation of the group's leaders".
Abul-Futuh said the group's aim was to clearly delineate "Brotherhood students
from those belonging to radical or violent trends." The term "Islamist" that
student Brotherhood members used to identify themselves with also tends to
include individuals from groups like Al-Gamaa Al-Islamiya, Jihad and the
Islamist-oriented Labour Party. Some of these groups were blamed for a wave of
terrorist violence in the 1990s.Brotherhood leaders denied the commonly
proffered explanation that the student protests were a form of
"muscle-flexing" in the lead up to November's parliamentary elections, in
which the Brotherhood plans to field over 100 candidates. "The students
themselves have repeatedly called for revealing their identity as members of
the group," said Abul-Futuh, "but we always refused because we were afraid
they would be detained by the police." Abul-Futuh said the current political
climate, with its "increased freedoms and fewer detentions," had catalysed
"the decision to support these demands now". According to students who took
part in the recent Cairo University demonstrations, only two of the protestors
were briefly detained. Diaa Rashwan, an analyst with Al-Ahram's Centre for
Political and Strategic Studies, said the Brotherhood had much to gain from
the student protests. "It is part of a broader trend in the Muslim Brotherhood
ranks," said Rashwan, an expert on Islamist affairs, "meant to exercise
greater pressure on the government to recognise the group by name; simply
speaking, it's an attempt by a group classified as outlawed to gain
legitimacy." Whether or not that is true, the Brotherhood clearly feels more
emboldened about having both a louder voice and a stronger presence on campus.
Cairo University is now dotted with Brotherhood banners as the group
prepares for upcoming student union elections. According to the weekly Rose
El-Youssef magazine, the Brotherhood has earmarked enough money to field
numerous candidates in these campaigns. The group has long slammed student
union elections as "rigged", marred by security interference, and marked by
the exclusion of popular Islamist-oriented students. "We want to change that
situation," said Abdel-Rahman El-Saidi, an Alexandria University-based member
of the group. The Brotherhood's increased presence also appeared to mobilise
students from other groups. Inspired by the bolder Brotherhood stance, student
members of the Islamist-oriented Labour Party are now planning to increase
their campus activities as well. Students from socialist groups as well as
more recently formed reform movements like Kifaya have also formed a coalition
to press jointly for their demands. Aida Seif El-Dawla, a leading member of
the Kifaya movement, joined the Brotherhood's Abul-Futuh at a press conference
this week declaring the formation of a student coalition. The speakers
highlighted that the newly cooperative atmosphere stems from a clear
understanding that only collective efforts would yield results. "Although we
disagree with the Brotherhood," said George Isaac, the coordinator of Kifaya,
"the students belonging to each group have to work together for a better
situation on campus overall." Isaac compared the current dynamic to the glory
days of Egypt's student movement in the early 1970s and early 1980s, when
demonstrations involving hundreds of thousands of students protested against
the harsh economic conditions prevalent at the time. These demonstrations
catalysed late president Anwar El-Sadat's decision to push through a new law
preventing students from taking part in political activities, including
confining their demonstrations to campus grounds. Some are worried, however,
that the revived student movement may also signify a rise in more militant
Islamism on campus. According to a recent Human Rights Watch report, most
non-state interference in university affairs actually comes from Islamist
militants, whose political activism is religious driven. "This group
intimidates professors and students through a variety of tactics, including
litigation and physical assaults," said the report, entitled The Repression of
Academic Freedom in Egyptian Universities.
|
|
 |